Our School

Our School

Sunday, January 17, 2010

Einstein Failed School

Now, this is what I would call a 'great' myth-buster...!!


At the end of the 20th Century, Time magazine voted Albert Einstein to be the Man of The Century. Albert was the dude who came up with all that really weird Relativity stuff - and he was your genuine certified Mega Brain. After all, we are told that he even won the Nobel Prize for his work in Relativity. On the other hand, generations of school kids have consoled themselves over their poor school marks with the belief that Einstein failed at school. Some motivational speakers also make this claim - but this claim is as wrong as the claim about the Nobel Prize.


First, Einstein did not win the 1921 Nobel Prize in Physics for his work on Relativity. Let's back up a little. Back in 1905, Einstein had the biggest year of his life. He wrote, with the help of his wife, Mileva, five ground-breaking papers that, according to the Encyclopaedia Britannica "forever changed Man's view of the Universe". Any scientist would have been proud to write even one of these magnificent papers - but Albert published five of them in one year!

One paper, of course, dealt with Relativity - what happens to objects as they move relative to other objects. Another paper proved that atoms and molecules had to exist, based on the fact that you could see tiny particles jigging around when you looked at a drop of water through a microscope. A third paper looked at a strange property of light - the Photoelectric Effect. Plants and solar cells do the Photoelectric Effect, when they turn light into electricity. His paper explained the Photoelectric Effect.

Relativity may have captured the public's consciousness, but it was the unglamorous Photoelectric Effect that got him the Nobel Prize. Well, that's one myth out of the way.

Second, Einstein definitely did not fail at high school. Einstein was born on 14 March in Ulm, in Germany, in 1879. The next year, his family moved to Munich. At the age of 7, he started school in Munich. At the age of 9, he entered the Luitpold-Gymnasium. By the age of 12 he was studying calculus. Now this was very advanced, because the students would normally study calculus when they were 15 years old. He was very good at the sciences. But, because the 19th-century German education system was very harsh and regimented, he didn't really develop his non-mathematical skills (such as history, languages, music and geography). In fact, it was his mother, not his school, who encouraged him to study the violin - and he did quite well at that as well.

In 1895, he sat the entrance examinations to get into the prestigious Federal Polytechnic School (or Academy) in Zurich, Switzerland. He was 16, two years younger than his fellow applicants. He did outstandingly well in physics and mathematics, but failed the non-science subjects, doing especially badly in French - so he was not accepted. So in that same year, he continued his studies at the Canton school in Aargau (also called Aarau). He studied well, and this time, he passed the entry exams into the Federal Polytechnic School.

So the next year, he finally started studying at the Federal Polytechnic in Zurich (even though he was now one year younger than most of his fellow students). Also in the year 1896, even though he was only 16 years old, he wrote a brilliant essay that led directly to his later work in relativity.

So he definitely did not fail his high school, and definitely was not a poor student.

So how did the myth that he failed high school start?

Easy. In 1896, which was Einstein's last year at the school in Aargau, the school's system of marking was reversed.

A grading of "6", which had previously been the lowest mark, was now the highest mark. And so, a grading of "1", which had been the highest mark, was now the lowest mark.

And so, anybody looking up Einstein's grades would see that he had scored lots of grades around "1" - which under the new marking scheme, meant a "fail".

And that means that schoolkids can't use that mythconception as a crutch any more - they'll just have to work harder...

By Karl S. Kruszelnicki(http://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2004/06/23/1115185.htm)

4 comments:

  1. thanks.. hehe
    uncle, i've been trying to convert the videos taken on the reunion day to some format which i can upload on youtube... but it seems like a "techie" job... Vishwanath(my brother, fortunately some1 u can call as a "techwiz"..hehe) is gonna b back at home for the weekend, n i'll tell him to do the job....
    Will try to upload the videos by monday..
    tc

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey bros Techie and Wizzie, by Monday i would have been on the air ( or Ether or where ??) with all that's from my handycam (full 19 of them). You better come out with something new. Good luck

    ReplyDelete
  3. Suresh, please post the latest 19 as the real-links to our re-union videos and move all the the older ones as a seperate group of links straight from the stone age.

    ReplyDelete

Members' Contact

Classmates
01. Rajalakshmi Unnikrishnan
02. Begum Zahira Rahman
03. Sivasankar
04. Jayaram
05. Suresh D Nair
06. Rajendran Nambiar
07. Venugopala Menon

08. Ramdas P K
09. Rajiv Anand
10. Sanal K V
11. Seny Kuriens
12. Ranjith Nayar

13. Reshma
14. Sobhitraj
15. Sunil M
16. Jyothi Unnikrishnan
17. Geetha Ramdas
18. Karunakaran
19. Juny
20. Sheela
21. Anup Kumar
22. Molly Varghese
23. Nagesh
24. Ranjana
25. Nitin Raj
26. Ragini Shah

27. Srilatha
28. Girija Nambiar
29. Dr Girish Kumar NV
30. Shanker Meembat

31. Premaja
32. Sudev
33. Ramesh Gopinath
34. Sanjay
35. Rajiv ET
36. Sunanda Rajendran
37. Mini Karur
38. Chetan Ramniklal Jamnadas Kotecha
39. Preetha Sasidharan
40. KC Madhavan
41. Madhu Rao

Teacher Members
01. Mr. Mohandas M
02. Mr. Appukutty
03. Mr. Chakkappan
04. Mr. Krishnan Nair P.V
05. Ms. Chitra C.C
06. Mr. Janardhanan K (Art)
07. Mr. Janardhanan P (W/ Exp)
08. Mr. Joseph P.V

09. Ms. Soudhamini
10. Ms. Julia Gracy (W/ Exp
11. Ms. Vijayalakshmi Achyunni
12. Ms. Maya Das
13. Ms. Radha P

14. Ms. Sarala Devi (Soc. Studies )
15. Ms. Sathi A.K


Non-Teaching Staff Members
01. Mr. Balachandran P.K (Chem lab )

02. Ms. Bhanumathy V (Office Staff)
03. Mr. Bhaskara Pillai (Physics Lab)
04. Mr. Chandran N.T & Ms. Savithri
05. Mr. Gopi C

The contact numbers and email ids of the members have been here for a while now and it is assumed that our members would have taken note of it by now. The same have been removed from here due to security reasons. In case, some of our members require the contact details they may contact any of the ids given below

This is not a comprehensive list – Please mail the details of the missing member classmate (xth 1977 & xiith - 1979) to sureshnair.nair@gmail.com or call on 91-9940648447; or Rajendran Nambiar / 97150 1949359/ rajnambiarkt@gmail.com or Sivasankar /9447455251 / sivasankar.sbi@gmail.com.